<!--quoteo(post=225008:date=Dec 9 2007, 07:09 AM:name=Pieter Boelen)--><div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(Pieter Boelen @ Dec 9 2007, 07:09 AM) [snapback]225008[/snapback]</div><div class='quotemain'><!--quotec-->As for the attack on Batavia: My original idea was that Jack causes a war between the EITC and the Dutch VOC, which would turn out being the mark he left on Beckett. The reason is that the VOC is the main trading company in Indonesia and is much more powerful at the time than the EITC. So Beckett loses a lot of ships, men and money this way. Therefore I would expect the EITC to LOSE the fight for Batavia. The way you describe it though is as if they would very much win the fight.
These are my thoughts:
Jack sets up the fight and makes it seem like a good opportunity for the EITC. Then he goes to Batavia and tells the Dutch of the upcoming attack. Then we get the siege of Batavia. The EITC soldiers manage to get into the town quite easily (similar to what you describe), but then they are ambushed by the Dutch and eventually the Dutch win. Then the Dutch fleet chases the EITC fleet and sinks many ships. This is seen by Jack from the top of Batavia city. Jack then goes to the beach to leave Indonesia as well, but finds that his ship is being burnt and sunk by Nathaniel Edwards. Jack says "YOU?" and Edwards replies "I am realy sorry about this, Jack. I truly am.", echoing what Jack said to Edwards when Jack captured Edwards and turned pirate. Edwards and Jack are on different sides, but still friendly. Jack let Edwards go after turning pirate and now Edwards lets Jack go. Jack is alone on the beach in the dark, his ship has been burnt and sunk and he swears he will get his ship back even if it's the last thing he does. He tries and raise the Wench from the bottom of the sea, almost drowns and meets Davy Jones. Davy raises the rechristened Black Pearl, but Jack is caught in the middle of the EITC fleet's escape from Indonesia. So we then have the EITC fleet being chased by the VOC fleet and Jack has to escape with the Pearl.<!--QuoteEnd--></div><!--QuoteEEnd-->
I think the Dutch HAVE to be eventually defeated by Beckett to pave the way for his fleet of 300 ships and ultimate economic rule over the seas. We could put a harder fight for the EITC, but i think with the right planning, and a good number of troops the EITC could actually capture Batavia. (Not mentioning Mercers cruelty in combat would give the EITC an edge intimidation wise). Mercer should have a reputation to the other trading companies and so they would become uneasy if they heard he was on his way with a whole host of EITC marines. Yes, the dutch can ambush them, and this hard hand-to-hand fight breaks out. Mercer, seeing them distracted could take a company down another street and flank them. Here's what i think the goals of the EITC are:
1) Gain entry.
2) Distract enemy soldiers.
3) Secure waterfront so enemy cant escape.
4) Have transport fleet escorts blockade the harbor to prevent any escape.
5) Annihilate any resistance.
6)Capture or kill the enemy General.
7)Capture enemy governor.
Then in the battle between Jones and Beckett, the VOC will show up with a task force to get revenge for the loss of their capital in the indies.