Swashing Buckler
Landlubber
periodaccuracy would of course clear up that problem making some weapons unavailable in some storylines, but i like it when I can have an inventory filled with all kind of stuffBartolomeu sent me some new weapons for the next modpack release. I reckon that with those added, we'll definitely have enough weapons.
I never did see the point of having a gazillion different weapons. The way I figure it, it adds a little more variety at the expense of being a lot more stuff for the player to scroll through.

of course finding a correct one may be frustrating i get it- but i like to have lots of stuff to scroll though

Best choice would be option to select either "all items" or just periodaccurate ones from advanced options but that may be infernal thing to do......
or better items-menu with more categories like "pistols and muskets", "armors" and "swords" as separate inventories there under weapons category(like there is separate category for weapons and maps etc. under inventory itself) - that would make it easier to find them... but may be hard to mod.....
oh and tarred leatherjacket could be one more "armor" since those provide protection from cutlasses etc. bit off-topic there but one more idea for future
