i'm guessing my high level (34) probably triggered this as i see in the guide that :
so i speak with davy jones , in the first line i ask him how does he know my name, but then he says i owe him for giving me the black pearl and...blah blah... gives me justine le moigne, while i am still with becketts ship.
Lucas the Admirals Son & Justine Le Moigne --- available after Curse of the Black Pearl - or before you get the Black Pearl from Davy Jones - if you have reached a certain level
so i speak with davy jones , in the first line i ask him how does he know my name, but then he says i owe him for giving me the black pearl and...blah blah... gives me justine le moigne, while i am still with becketts ship.