Question only game

[Meigger]

Weren't the biscuits burned?

 

[Old Salt]

Why were they burned?

 

[Stallion]

Who stole my biscuits?

 

[Meigger]

How do you know they were stolen?

 

[Stallion]

Didn't you see the empty plate?

 

[Meigger]

An empty plate doesn't mean they were stolen does it?

 

[extra crispy]

Maybe you ate them, then suffered a head trauma thus removing any memory of the incident?
What if one of your other personalities ate them?
What if you drank too much that day?
What if you ate it while sleep walking?

 

[Meigger]

It wasn't me, was it you?

 

[Stallion]

Why so many questions? :

 

[extra crispy]

Just pointing out the possibilities. Have you considered them?

 

[Meigger]

Was someone sleep walking?

 

[Stallion]

What if they didn't know they were?

 

[Meigger]

Would someone not know?

 

[Stallion]

Doesn't the word "sleepwalking" imply not knowing you're walking, 'cuz you're asleep? :

 

[Meigger]

True. But someone would know if they saw you right?

 

[Stallion]

True, but what if that person lied about seeing you? :robber:

 

[Meigger]

Why would they lie? :

 

[extra crispy]

To mess with you?

 

[Stallion]

In what way?

 

[Meigger]

What way do you choose?