This week's movie classic doesn't cover just one movie but rather two quite different adaptations of the same story. Mutiny on the Bounty is
a real event in 1789, where the crew of
H.M.S. Bounty rose to mutiny. The stories of both presented movies revolves around the two men, the captain and his first mate, driven into extreme measures, but each movie takes a very different approach into how and why the famous mutiny came to be.
Mutiny on the Bounty (1935) is a faithful filmatization of
the book of the same name, written by
Charles Nordhoff and
James Norton Hall.
In this movie, Captain William Bligh (
Charles Laughton) is a clear cut villain – he is a ruthless taskmaster willing to go to any lenghts in order to keep the crew of
H.M.S. Bounty in line, including flogging a dead man. The first mate Fletcher Christian (
Clark Cable) despises captain Bligh and his methods, and when Bligh's cruelty inadvertedly causes the death of the ship's doctor, Christian leads the crew into mutiny and takes control of the ship.
After the mutiny, Christian and the crew take permanent anchor at Tahiti, and send Captain Bligh and those loyal to him adrift in a skiff, to navigate home as they please. Thru a combination of willpower and luck, Bligh and his loyalists navigate the seas for almost two months, reaching Dutch East Indies without losing a single hand on the tiny vessel. They return to England, report the mutiny, and set sail to Tahiti to recapture H.M.S. Bounty and bring justice to the mutineers.
When Bligh's new ship is sighted, Christian and his crew flee by setting sail with the
Bounty. They eventually land on Pitcairn Island and found a colony there.
Mutiny on the Bounty takes several liberties with historical accuracy, but is, in the end, considered to be the best cinematic work inspired by the real events. It was nominated for six Oscar Awards, of which
Mutiny on the Bounty won the Oscar for Best Picture. In the Best Actor category,
Mutiny on the Bounty had three of its actors nomineed, which speaks volumes about how well acted this epoch is.
[video=youtube;OtmV2tpbnjA]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OtmV2tpbnjA[/video]
Whereas
Mutiny on the Bounty is a rather black-and-white, albeit entertaining, version of the mutiny,
The Bounty (1984) muddles it into shades of grey.
H.M.S. Bounty has been stranded at Tahiti for months, during which time the crew of the ship grow fond of the leisurely life and easy pleasures the island has to offer. Some crew members take wives, including first mate Fletcher (
Mel Gibson). When Captain Bligh (
Anthony Hopkins), portrayed as a honorable, proud and moral man, tries to return to sea and bring the crew of his ship back into discipline, he is met with resistance unfitting to men of the royal navy. Bit by bit captain Bligh's disciplinary choices grow harsher, and finally the crew mutinees, both to topple the now-tyrannous captain from his seat of power, but also out of longing to be able to return to Tahiti and continue their lives away from the command of the British flag.
Fletcher and the crew sail back to Tahiti only to find that they are no longer welcome – the Tahitians fear that the actions of the crew will bring the full wrath of King George on them, so they drive the outlanders away. Forced to find another safe harbor, the crew eventually lands on Pitcairn Island, and burn the Bounty in order to remain hidden from the British Navy.
Captain Bligh returns to England and is found not guilty for losing his ship in the mutiny.
The Bounty is a far more realistic depiction of the real mutiny, and it is both gritty and grimy, but also very intelligent – there are no bad guys in this movie, only people with strong but incompatible loyalties.
Again, the movie is full of excellent acting. In lack of proper trailer, this collage of captain Bligh's outbursts in his attempts to control his crew will do.
[video=youtube;wUlgVqSeLRk]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wUlgVqSeLRk [/video]