• New Horizons on Maelstrom
    Maelstrom New Horizons


    Visit our website www.piratehorizons.com to quickly find download links for the newest versions of our New Horizons mods Beyond New Horizons and Maelstrom New Horizons!

Pirates of the Caribbean Online

Captain Monty

Landlubber
Hello All

Surprisingly no one here seems to be talking about POTCO yet, so rare poster though I am I thought I would raise the subject...

I started an account a week or so ago (with a much more Piratey name than this one) without expecting much due to the distinctly odd looking cartoony ship graphics and a number of reports of bugs and the like - not surprising in a newly launched game.

Some of the criticisms levelled at it are reasonable - fair to middling graphics, a fair bit of lag, no character customization after the initial creation, linear quest-lines and limited weapon choices, but........ actually..... it's GREAT ! I absolutely love it so far, and for reasons I think you lot will appreciate.

After creating your character (loads of options, but get it right - you can't change it afterwards, oh, and the hat choice is rubbish!) you follow some instructional quests to familiarise yourself wth the game and eventually end up on Port Royal - at which point you can carry on with various other instructions based quests or have your first proper go in your new Sloop. Answer to "Question 1" for all proper Pirates Ahoy types is YES, you can and must walk the deck (or decks). When you eventually (in my case) pluck up the courage to interract with other players you will find that you can bring them onto your ship (or go to theirs) as crew. Someone, not necessarily the captain (owner) of the ship takes the helm and everyone else roams the decks until they are required to man the cannons. Once he or she has taken charge of the wheel the captain gets a pan-able view from above and initially behind the ship so that they can see enough to navigate. Broadside cannons can only be fired by the captain and take a long time to reload, all other cannons must be individually manned by people and have a much faster reload rate.
Whilst the ships do have a weird simplified Disneyesque look about them the combat graphics are actually excellent - splinters fly everywhere, the decks shudder, dirty great holes get blown in hulls (yours and your enemies) sails get torn and masts come down. There is a full day/night cycle too, so, combine all that lot with a beautifully atmospheric sunrise or sunset and you very much start to "get it".

But that's not the best bit (nearly finished :) ). Long story short: Last night me and my crew of four went out on my light frigate (can carry a maximum of eight crew), and among other types of ships attacked a "Flagship". These are boardable. The crew ran from one side of the ship to the other to fire the cannons (not fully manned you see) according to which side I needed to present, then when enough damage was done (at which point green "boarding targets" appear) fired grappling hooks at the ship until we were secure. At this point I (as helmsman at the time) pressed the boarding button. This results in all (not all sometimes, but I won't go into that) of us swinging over (yes - you see yourself doing it) onto the other ship and battling the crew with our cutlasses. This is just great - you really feel like you are there - particularly since you can see your own ship bobbing away alongside too. All this happens in real time - you can watch other crews do it from afar if you wish. After we had in this case (OK - we often lose) beaten the crew, we swung back onto our own ship and watched the ship we attacked sink - providing us with an amount of plunder. We carried on like this until the hold was full then in traditional manner went back to Tortuga and
divided the plunder. The game does that automatically according to how much you took part, and the Captain gets a little extra to pay for repairs to the ship if required. If you lose by the way you just end up in the nearest jail and have to escape again, you don't lose anything other than damage to your ship. If you are the captain and get "killed" then your ship stays out there with what's left of the crew if it has not sunk.

Now, it may not have POTCs beauty and complexity (I have been playing the various Mod versions for years and it can't be beaten yet), but that's proper pirate stuff that :)

Hard-core MMORPGers are unlikely to like it since it's very much a pick up and play for occasional fun affair - not much grinding, no trading at all, very few shops and really not that much apart from ships and weapons to spend your hard earned booty on. For me that's perfect since I am married with a pretty full life so would never have the time to play a proper "grinder". Mind you, POTBS might tempt me...

You can play the initial game for free by the way - but it's with Flash ads enabled (which still cause serious lag despite a couple of patches), in a window and you can only buy the basic ship. You can still crew on the big shops though. I have paid for the full game for a month to come now and very definitely do not regret it. I did this despite being a UK resident - you just take the space out of your Post code and choose whichever US state the automatic selector takes as it's best guess for that code. There are still a few small bugs, the occasional disconnect and a little lag, but this is Disney, they will no doubt fix it.

Blimey - I was only going to write a few lines. Thankyou for reading if you got this far...
 
MMh i tried the basic account for PotC Online ..

The best about PotC Online, is the crew game play .. Beeing with 10 ppl on a frigate is rly cool.
That open a natural way of Roleplay, and it works great. So every1 calling the owner of the Ship cap' and the follow his word.
But its much too restricted for basic gameplay. The advertising for the Full Version is annoying.And There are just a few quests for the basic account. The Grafic isnt rly good, it looks ugly.

Iam more a fan of realistic and historical correctness, so the game is nothing for me.
Iam waiting for PofBS <img src="style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/biggrin.gif" style="vertical-align:middle" emoid=":D" border="0" alt="biggrin.gif" />.
 
Free, you say? That's wonderful. We might be able to, um, "liberate" some stuff <img src="style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/biggrin.gif" style="vertical-align:middle" emoid=":D" border="0" alt="biggrin.gif" />

Anyway, from what I've heard from youtube videos, PotCO has another nice stuff: the music. You know, I am rather dissapointed that Hans Zimmer choose to base his scores on new stuff, which means that familiar leitmotivs from the first movie are almost absent from DMC and AWE, which is a shame, since they were pretty cool sounding, and stuff Zimmer made doesn't quite compare to that. Well, maybe with the exception of his love theme, which itself was remade into Ennio Morriconish "Parlay" tune (the one that plays when Jack, Barbossa and Queen Liz parlay with Beckett, Davy and Will <img src="style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/smile.gif" style="vertical-align:middle" emoid=":)" border="0" alt="smile.gif" /> )

But the PotCO composer, from what I could hear, isn't above recycling tunes and rearranging them into diferent themes. Whose sound rather nice, I must say <img src="style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/biggrin.gif" style="vertical-align:middle" emoid=":D" border="0" alt="biggrin.gif" />
 
by the sound of it, you guys would love puzzle pirates. it's very similar, but on a way grander scale. a war frigate can carry 70 crew, for instance, of which 50 are actually needed, and that's not even the biggest ship! the thing that you might critisize about this game is that everything's a puzzle, so you're not right in the action apart from the ship battles. what's more, the game hardly has any NPC's. all shops, tournaments, factories and just about everything else is run by real players! if you're lucky, you might even end up as the major of an island. of course, if your island gets blockaded by a flag of 300 permanent members and maybe the same about of jobbers, you're in pretty big trouble unless some bold even huger flag chooses to lift the blockade. the game's largely free, and the things that aren't free can be gotten without paying for it anyway, for the most part. legally, i assure you. although it probably wouldn't exactly scare me if it wasn't. the game's often updated, and new content is added very frequently, often being seasonal. i wonder what they have in stall for us this christmas.
 
Yeah, but does it have <i>Black Pearl</i> in it? <img src="style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/smile.gif" style="vertical-align:middle" emoid=":)" border="0" alt="smile.gif" />

Anyhoo, turns out that free portion of PotCO doesn't actually allow you to finish the quest that would give you access to the <i>Black Pearl</i> (which, judging from screenshots, it's not bad lookin'). The whole thing is moot anyway, since I can't get PotCO to work with my ripper <img src="style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/sad.gif" style="vertical-align:middle" emoid=":(" border="0" alt="sad.gif" />
 
well, it does have a black ship that avenges noobs that have been attacked by players they couldn't possibly defeat, which is a good counter-measure. before you start looking for the game, you have to know that if i'd refer you by email, you'd get a starting bonus when creating your first character.
 
I may come from the country that made LEGO, but that doesnt mean I like the graphics in PotCO...

What a shitty game to look at, notice how short and fast they pan away from the ship battle scenes in the promotion trailers <img src="style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/biggrin.gif" style="vertical-align:middle" emoid=":D" border="0" alt="biggrin.gif" />

From the statements people make about this game in the interviews, they would feint if they experienced PotC: New Horizons...
 
I like Lego ! I saw the built version of Lego's Millenium Falcon yesterday and all I can say is... Oh my God.... It's about a metre wide and has every last pipe detailed..... and costs £350 ($700) ! Wish I was still a kid, a rich one, obviously.

However, yes, the game battles do look terrible in the trailers, and the videos on You-Tube are all from early versions as far as I can tell. It works because of the crew co-operation, not because of how it looks. I love to play good looking games, but gameplay goes over graphics every time for me. I will of course be playing New Horizons and POTBS too. Both will be excellent no doubt, but I suspect neither will give a feeling of "being there" like the boarding sequence of POTCO since they use "instances" which don't match the ship you happen to be using or indeed attacking.

Now Puzzle Pirates is something I have mulled over as a possible for a time. I can tell from the site updates that the people who run it care about support and variety, but like many people I was put off by the idea of everything being puzzle based - largely because on the whole I don't really do puzzle games. I might still revisit that and when I do I will come begging to you Captain Morgan :) I love the idea of a ship that avenges Noobs - a lot of PVP games could do with something like that.

I did decide to play a browser based game (correct me if I am wrong but I think PP is browser based ?) at work, but eventually plumped for Pirate Quest (I did have an account with a similar game (the one several of yourselves played I think) but that account decided to stop working for some reason). However the company I work for has put up a Web Filter which has spoilt my lunchtimes for the moment. I still play occasionally of an evening but of course cannot devote enough time to get anywhere as yet.

Must see if PP is stopped by that web-filter since strangely it does not stop traffic from Piratesonline.com, so technically I could download the game and play it at work (albeit from a Mac), but there are all sorts of dire measures threatened for those who use work machines for games so I have not dared yet.

It's true by the way that the free account limits what you can do in POTCO to a big degree, but it's just right for giving you a taster and you can still experience some of the bigger quests simply by signing on to the crew of a bigger ship. I have found the players to be surprisingly helpful and I think Disney's no nonsense "no bad behaviour of any kind will be tolerated" approach is absolutely the right one. Of course it helps that PVP is extremely limited (a couple of locations and I'm note sure you can do it at all if you have not paid), if they had made it a PVP environment then they would probably have ended up with the occasional bullying hatefest that is the otherwise excellent "World of Pirates". Mind you - that's part of the thrill of WOP, real Pirates weren't nice people after all.... and in fact there are plenty of really good sorts there too.

Music wise, the main theme's from the first film are all there and yes, some have been modified a little. For me though there could be a lot more variety to the music. If they can't use more location specific themes then they could probably replace the regularly used ones occasionally - although this would no doubt mean a bigger footprint on your hard drive. Definitely agree that the second and third films could have used the main theme a little more, but I did like the big orchestra and Organ themes used for the sinking of the ship by the Kraken and the big blow-up ending and would like to see them appear in the game (perhaps they do for the big quests - I'm not really doing that right now, just bumming around mostly).

Have a good evening all.

Captain Monty
 
well, PP works like this:

you download the program from the site. then, you can play the game from your own computer. of course, this is an issue if you haven't a lot of space, cos it's really big for an online game by my standards. the thing is, everything is on your computer (i think), so the game doesn't lag very much, even on 20kb internet, which i have. once in a while, at intervals of a week at the moment, there's an update which you get a message about if you start the game up. there's one major one-time glitch in the game though: for some odd reason, your first character profile doesn't work right. you can't log in for a second time if you log off. however, the second profile and all the ones after that work fine. i'd recommend to download the game NOT following the link in the recommendation email, start a character, log off, and THEN use the link in the recommendation email to start your second character. i'm not sure if this works though. you might not have the starting bonus for your second character. bigger problem: i wouldn't get MY reward either! <img src="style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/icon_wink.gif" style="vertical-align:middle" emoid=";)" border="0" alt="icon_wink.gif" />
 
Hmmn - very interesting, that probably explains why I didn't go for the game at work (or perhaps I was thinking of Dogs of the the Seas, I can't remember).

I'll give it a try when I tire of POTCO - which no doubt I will, I'm a bit of a non-finisher where games are concerned - although I did finish Tortuga Two Treasures (good - much better than people think) mentioned in the thread next door. I wrote a small "essay" on that too, but when I uploaded it the text was lost and I couldn't be bothered to re-write it (should have copied it to word pad before sending).

Great to come across someone who still has a dial-up connection, broadband isn't always the answer - I signed up for it a week or two back (yes, you guessed why) and have been very disappointed by the speeds achieved - probably because of where my particular telephone exchange is. Must ask my opposite neighbour what speeds she gets :) Will look at my internal extension leads too.
 
Back
Top