Stuck

[Agomezca]

Ahoy there! I’m at the point when you talk to barbossa in Puerto Rico and he tells you to find the missing guy in an island. Looked in the wiki and just found that I need to sail south and enter a cave through the jungle. The thing is that the island south of Puerto Rico is Isla Mona, and I can’t find a way to get to the shore, there is no option. Another island south of Puerto Rico is Nevis, however, I don’t find the cave anywhere hahaha . Thank you very much!

 

[Grey Roger]

There is another island a lot closer. If youve ever played the sidequest "Strange Things Going On in the Caribbean" then you'll know the one. "Hoist the Colours" has its own version of that quest which leads somewhere else, so it can do other things with that island...